The new Director of PSA, Johnny Warren, kicked off Now or Never by addressing the PSA Faithful. He welcomed everyone to this new era, and he promised that we would see The Lifeblood Initiative in full effect tonight. Next, he declared that due to Corwin’s brutal attack on Brittany Blake at Finest Hour, “The Devil’s Chosen One” is banned from ever challenging for the PSA World Championship while Warren is in charge. With that out of the way, “The Lifeblood” turned his attention to Josh Grabowski. He explained that after doing everything he could to help Josh become PSA World Champion, he was disgusted to see him celebrate with Andrew, the man who stabbed him in the back and cost him that Title in the first place. But taking that out of the equation, Grabowski simply wasn’t a good Champion; he barely showed up, and when he did, he either lost or ended matches in countout draws. PSA deserved better, so Warren gave them better by gifting that Title to someone new: Keith. Speaking of, Johnny warned Keith that if he fails PSA like Josh did, he will destroy him and find someone better. To end his speech, Warren clarified that he and Josh will never face off in the ring, they will never make amends, and Josh will never be PSA World Champion ever again.
20 of PSA’s best competed in the Now or Never Battle Royal, with the winner earning a Championship match of their choosing tonight. Several wrestlers made their PSA debut here, including The High Five’s Maximilien Plouffe and Sir Alex Westworthy. There was also a random old person named Spoonman, but the current belief is that this was a fan who snuck his way into the match Most wrestlers held their own, but Allen, who has officially joined the PSA roster, walked out on top when he last eliminated Mark Cooper Jr.
Trunk faced off with Undkban once again, but this time it was inside After Hours Anarchy. With no ropes and the only ways to win being knockout or submission, both men took this match to the extreme. Trunk proved that his resilience is better than most, but everyone has their limit; as he ran at his opponent with a headbutt, he was knocked out cold by Undkban’s Sands of Time. During Undkban’s celebration, however, the PSA Faithful were shocked to see the return of Cali Dynamite, who hit “The Pharaoh” in the back with a steel chair! Dynamite never forgot who injured him over a year ago, and he has officially aligned with The Lifeblood Initiative in order to get his revenge.
Cheese Louise, Swashbucklin’ Sheri, La Biblioteca, Hayley, Cruella Castonova, and Brittany Blake competed in the Women’s Debt Collection Ladder Match. Blake, who has fully committed to The Lifeblood Initiative following Corwin’s attack at Finest Hour, finally embraced the aggressive tendencies that she was teasing for months. This, along with a newfound partnership in The Lifeblood Initiative’s fourth member, Cruella Castonova, helped Blake retrieve the briefcase and become the 2025 Women’s Debt Collector.
One of PSA’s newest stars, Rasgón, competed against the returning and reborn Hernando Muertes. In a fantastic matchup, Rasgón came out on top when he reversed the Midnight Driver into the Ledger Shredder. Even so, either man could have walked out on top, and it will not be long before these two meet in the ring once again.
Next, The Owskis faced The Disciples for the first time ever. With no chance of getting revenge against Johnny Warren, Josh and Andrew are on a quest to recapture the PSA Tag Team Championship. Luckily for them, the PSA Faithful are fully behind this pairing, and they proved how deserving they are of this support in this match of the year contender. While Drov and Grabowski were brawling at ringside, Frankowski hit Draco with the Sandbag to give The Owskis their second win of the year. As Draco and Drov recovered in the ring, they were attacked by JX2, who have also pledged themselves to The Lifeblood Initiative! Are The Disciples their first target?
After winning the Now or Never Battle Royal earlier in the night, Allen chose to challenge Drew Pender for the PSA Hardcore Championship. In a competitive Hardcore Classic, “The Shepherd of Fire” bested Allen with the What Goes Up Must Come Down to continue his reign as Champion.
The Main Event of the evening was the Men’s Debt Collection Ladder Match. Samuel Binglebottom, Goldielox, Gilgadar, Leonard Lopez, and the returning Ben Richards were all announced ahead of time, but no one knew who the final participant would be. Johnny Warren promised earlier in the night that he ensured that only the best would leave with the Debt Collector, and his way of doing so was by entering himself into the match! In the contest itself, Ben Richards shook Warren’s hand to signify that he was the seventh and final member of The Lifeblood Initiative. As Richards tried to help Warren retrieve the briefcase, however, he was taken out by his brother, Samuel Binglebottom. This gave Goldielox the opportunity to climb the ladder, knock Warren off, and become the 2025 Men’s Debt Collector!