Tara had her sister, Hayley, had some personal issues for months, but the two put it aside at Finest Hour 2025 to defeat Marcia and Swashbucklin' Sheri and crown another member of Ashes of the Spear as a Champion.

After earning a rematch for the Roster Roulette Championship at Ultimate Hour Anniversary Edition, Swashbucklin' Sheri defeated Janice Janet to become the first two-time Roster Roulette Champion.  After having a remarkable 182-day reign, Hayley held back Sheri to ensure that Tara could capture the Gold at Finest Hour 2025.

DEFENSES:

1. Yuri Blade- Halloween from Hell (October 31, 2024)

2. Marcia, Brittany Blake, Cheese Louise, and Cruella Castonova- New Year's Arrival (January 2, 2025)

Janice Janet shocked everyone when she bested Swashbucklin' Sheri and Low-Key Eve at Fallout to become the fourth holder of the Roster Roulette Championship!  In a rematch with Swashbucklin' Sheri at Ultimate Hour Anniversary Edition, her 28-day reign came to an end in a Special Guest Referee match.

Swashbucklin' Sheri finally accomplished her goal of winning Championship Gold when she defeated Brittany Blake in a Street Fight on Ground Zero III Night Two to become Roster Roulette Champion.  Her arrogance got the best of her, as she lost it only 28 days layer in a 3 Way match against Janice Janet and Low-Key Eve.

Brittany Blake became the second-ever Roster Roulette Champion when she bested Hayley 4-3 in an Iron Woman match at Finest Hour.  After reigniting her feud with Swashbucklin' Sheri, Blake's reign came to an end when Trina Cooper cost her the Title during a Street Fight with Sheri on Night Two of Ground Zero III.

DEFENSES:

1. Macho Mars- Now or Never (April 25, 2024)

2. Swashbucklin' Sheri- Carnival of Conquest (May 23, 2024)

Hayley became the inaugural Roster Roulette Champion when she defeated Janice Janet at Ground Zero II Night Two in a Blindfold match.  Her incredible reign came to an end at 2024's edition of Finest Hour, where she was defeated by Brittany Blake in an Iron Woman match.

DEFENSES:

1. La Biblioteca- Ultimate Hour Anniversary Edition (September 21, 2023) 

2. Cactus Jaq- Ultimate Hour (October 12, 2023) 

3. Azura- Ultimate Hour Thanksgiving Sin (November 23, 2023)

4. Yuri Blade and Swashbucklin' Sheri- Christmas Calamity (December 15, 2023)